Carnegie Hill is one of Manhattan’s most charming and refined neighborhoods, known for its historic townhouses, tree-lined streets, and close-knit community feel. While it may be quieter than downtown, Carnegie Hill offers some of the most reliable and underrated pizza spots in Manhattan—perfect for locals, families, and anyone seeking classic New York flavor without the crowds.
If you’re searching for best pizza in Carnegie Hill, Upper East Side pizza, or neighborhood pizza spots in Manhattan, this ranked guide highlights the top pizza places in Carnegie Hill you’ll want to know about.
1. Patsy’s Pizzeria (Near Carnegie Hill)
Best Overall Pizza Near Carnegie Hill
A true New York institution, Patsy’s Pizzeria sits just steps from Carnegie Hill and remains one of the most respected pizza spots on the Upper East Side.
Why it ranks #1:
-
Legendary coal-fired oven
-
Thin, crisp crust with smoky flavor
-
Consistently excellent pies
-
Deep Upper East Side roots
2. Mimi’s Pizza (Yorkville / Carnegie Hill Border)
Best Classic Neighborhood Slice
Mimi’s Pizza is a go-to for locals craving a dependable, no-frills New York slice in a relaxed setting.
Why locals love it:
-
Traditional thin-crust slices
-
Generous portions
-
Friendly, neighborhood vibe
3. San Matteo Pizza Espresso Bar (Carnegie Hill)
Best Neapolitan-Style Pizza in Carnegie Hill
San Matteo brings authentic Italian flair to Carnegie Hill with wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pizzas made with high-quality ingredients.
Standout features:
-
Light, blistered crust
-
Fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce
-
Cozy, European café atmosphere
4. Piccola Cucina Uptown (Near Carnegie Hill)
Best Elevated Sit-Down Pizza Experience
Known for its Sicilian roots, Piccola Cucina offers refined pizzas in a polished, welcoming setting.
Why it makes the list:
-
High-quality ingredients
-
Comfortable dine-in experience
-
Great for casual dinners and date nights
5. Sauce Pizzeria (Upper East Side)
Best Everyday Pizza Option
Sauce Pizzeria is ideal for quick lunches, family takeout, or easy weeknight dinners near Carnegie Hill.
Why it works:
-
Consistent New York–style slices
-
Multiple UES locations
-
Convenient and reliable
6. Marinara Pizza (Upper East Side)
Best Budget-Friendly Pizza Near Carnegie Hill
Marinara Pizza is a solid choice for affordable, straightforward slices without sacrificing flavor.
What to expect:
-
Classic cheese and pepperoni slices
-
Casual grab-and-go vibe
-
Popular with students and locals
How We Ranked the Best Pizza in Carnegie Hill
Our rankings are based on:
-
Pizza quality and consistency
-
Proximity to Carnegie Hill
-
Neighborhood reputation
-
Overall dining experience
We prioritized spots that locals return to, not just places that trend online.
Final Slice: Why Carnegie Hill Is a Hidden Pizza Gem
Carnegie Hill’s pizza scene reflects the neighborhood itself, classic, dependable, and quietly excellent. While it may not be flashy, it delivers comfort-driven pizza experiences that fit seamlessly into everyday Upper East Side life.
If you’re exploring Manhattan neighborhood by neighborhood, Carnegie Hill deserves a spot on your pizza map—especially if you value quality, calm, and consistency.
