The Upper West Side (UWS) is known for its tree-lined streets, cultural landmarks, and strong sense of community. Alongside its classic neighborhood charm, the UWS offers a reliable and well-loved pizza scene, featuring everything from traditional New York slices to chef-driven, sit-down pizzerias.
If you’re searching for best pizza in Upper West Side NYC, Upper West Side pizza spots, or where to eat pizza in Manhattan, this ranked guide highlights the top pizza places on the Upper West Side, trusted by locals and visitors alike.
1. Sal & Carmine’s Pizza (Upper West Side)
Best Overall Pizza on the Upper West Side
Sal & Carmine’s is a legendary Upper West Side slice shop that perfectly captures classic New York pizza culture.
Why it ranks #1:
-
Thin, foldable slices
-
Perfect balance of cheese and sauce
-
Decades-long neighborhood favorite
2. Mama’s TOO! (Upper West Side)
Best Square Pizza on the Upper West Side
Mama’s TOO! has gained cult status for its thick, Sicilian-style square slices with crispy edges.
Why locals love it:
-
Pillowy interior with crunchy crust
-
Bold toppings and flavors
-
Always in high demand
3. Motorino (Upper West Side)
Best Neapolitan-Style Pizza on the UWS
Motorino delivers wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas using high-quality ingredients in a relaxed setting.
Standout features:
-
Light, blistered crust
-
Authentic Italian techniques
-
Great sit-down option
4. Made in New York Pizza (Upper West Side)
Best Everyday Slice Shop
A dependable option for quick meals, Made in New York Pizza delivers classic New York slices at a great value.
Why it makes the list:
-
Consistent quality
-
Convenient locations
-
Excellent for grab-and-go
5. Celeste (Upper West Side)
Best Roman-Style Pizza on the Upper West Side
Celeste offers Roman-style pizza in an intimate, neighborhood-focused setting.
What to expect:
-
Thin, crisp crust
-
Carefully sourced ingredients
-
Cozy dining experience
6. Marinara Pizza (Upper West Side)
Best Late-Night Pizza on the UWS
Marinara Pizza is a trusted spot for late-night slices and delivery on the Upper West Side.
Why it works:
-
Open late
-
Large slices
-
Affordable pricing
How We Ranked the Best Pizza on the Upper West Side
Our rankings are based on:
-
Pizza quality and consistency
-
Local reputation and longevity
-
Variety of pizza styles
-
Overall Upper West Side dining experience
The UWS excels at comfort, tradition, and dependable flavor.
Final Slice: Why the Upper West Side Is a Pizza Lover’s Classic
The Upper West Side remains one of Manhattan’s most reliable neighborhoods for great pizza. Whether you’re craving a classic slice, a thick square pie, or an authentic Neapolitan experience, the UWS delivers quality, community, and flavor in every bite.
