Greenwich Village isn’t just one of Manhattan’s most charming and historic neighborhoods, it’s also home to some of the greatest pizza in New York City. From legendary slice shops to centuries-old coal ovens, “The Village” has long been a pilgrimage zone for pizza lovers from all over the world.
Whether you’re living in the neighborhood, strolling through Washington Square Park, or planning your first NYC food adventure, these top pizza spots in Greenwich Village guarantee flavor, character, and the unmistakable energy that makes the Village feel like home.
Let’s dig into the best places to grab a slice (or five).
1. Joe’s Pizza — The Slice That Defines NYC
A Greenwich Village institution since 1975, Joe’s Pizza on Carmine Street is the ultimate New York slice. Ask any local where to go for a “real” NYC slice, and they’ll point you here—no hesitation.
What makes it iconic:
-
Perfectly thin crust
-
Balanced sauce
-
Classic New York fold
You’ll spot students, office workers, tourists, celebrities—all lined up for the same perfect slice. It’s the Village’s most essential pizza experience.
2. John’s of Bleecker Street — Coal-Fired Perfection Since 1929
If Joe’s is the king of slices, John’s of Bleecker is the king of whole pies. Their coal-fired oven turns out pizzas with a smoky flavor and crispness you simply can’t replicate elsewhere.
Must-know details:
-
No slices—whole pies only
-
Cash-only
-
Some of the best crust in Manhattan
This is a sit-down, shared-pie kind of place, perfect for dates, weekend groups, or anyone craving classic heritage-style pizza.
3. Artichoke Basille’s — Heavy, Indulgent, and Totally Worth It
Known citywide for its decadent Artichoke Slice, this spot has become a modern NYC icon. The Village location is always buzzing, and the pizza here is unapologetically rich and satisfying.
Try these slices:
-
Artichoke slice (creamy + crispy edges)
-
Crab slice
-
Vodka slice
It’s the kind of pizza you dream about later.
4. Bleecker Street Pizza — A Local Favorite with Award-Winning Flavor
A longtime Greenwhich Village staple, Bleecker Street Pizza is known for its fresh ingredients and consistent quality. Their signature Nonna Maria slice, topped with fresh mozzarella and basil, frequently wins “Best Slice in NYC” awards.
Why locals love it:
-
Casual, fast, and reliable
-
Thin-crust specialty slices
-
Ideal for late-night cravings
If you want a comforting, classic NYC moment, this is a must-stop.
5. Prince Street Pizza — Famous for Its Pepperoni Squares
Technically just outside the core Village but always included in local pizza routes, Prince Street Pizza is legendary for its thick, crispy pepperoni squares—tiny curled cups of spicy pepperoni stacked on golden, airy dough.
What to expect:
-
Long lines
-
Huge, satisfying squares
-
Instagram-famous slices that actually live up to the hype
Bring your appetite… and maybe some napkins.
6. Pizza Mercato — A Hidden Gem with Big Flavor
Located on busy West 3rd Street, Pizza Mercato manages to stand out thanks to its creative pies and super-fresh ingredients. It’s a favorite among NYU students and locals who want something a little more modern.
Fan favorites:
-
Truffle mushroom slice
-
Buffalo chicken slice
-
Grandma square
Fast, convenient, and surprisingly elevated.
7. Ben’s Pizzeria — Simple, Classic, Comforting
Directly across from NYU’s campus, Ben’s is the quintessential Village slice shop: simple, affordable, old-school, and incredibly comforting. It’s the kind of pizza spot you fall in love with unexpectedly.
Perfect for:
✔ After-class bites
✔ Late-night visits
✔ Classic cheese or pepperoni slices
Sometimes the best slice is the one that feels like home.
Why Greenwich Village Is NYC’s Pizza Paradise
Greenwich Village blends old New York, student culture, creative energy, and decades of culinary tradition, and that mix creates some of the best pizza in the entire city.
If you’re exploring NYC or deciding which Manhattan neighborhood to highlight next, the Village is a must for any pizza lover.
