Midtown Manhattan is one of the busiest and most diverse neighborhoods in New York City, and its pizza scene reflects that energy. From classic New York–style slices to authentic Neapolitan pies, Midtown offers some of the best pizza in Manhattan for locals, office workers, and visitors alike.
If you’re searching for best pizza in Midtown Manhattan, pizza near Times Square, or top NYC pizza spots, this guide highlights the most reliable and well-loved places to grab a slice in Midtown.
Why Midtown Manhattan Is a Pizza Hotspot
Midtown’s central location makes it a hub for some of the most accessible pizza places in NYC. With major transit lines, late-night dining, and constant foot traffic, Midtown pizzerias are built for quality and speed.
Let’s dive into the best of the best.
1. Joe’s Pizza — A New York Classic That Never Misses
Joe’s Pizza consistently ranks among the best New York pizza slices. Known for its thin crust, balanced sauce, and perfect cheese ratio, it’s a must-visit for anyone craving authentic NYC pizza.
Why it’s popular:
-
Iconic New York–style pizza
-
Quick service for busy Midtown crowds
-
A top choice for tourists and locals
2. Don Antonio — Where Wood-Fired Meets Neapolitan Tradition
Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in Midtown
For those craving something elevated, Don Antonio delivers authentic Neapolitan pizza in NYC using imported Italian ingredients.
Why it’s unique:
-
Certified Neapolitan techniques
-
High-quality mozzarella and sauces
-
Popular near Times Square
3. NY Pizza Suprema — A True Slice-Lover’s Paradise
Legendary Pizza Near Penn Station
NY Pizza Suprema is a longtime favorite and one of the most trusted names in Midtown Manhattan pizza.
Why it stands out:
-
Family-owned pizza institution
-
Classic slices and specialty pies
-
Ideal for commuters
4. Upside Pizza — Fun, Flavorful, and Perfect for Quick Bites
Upside Pizza brings playful toppings and bold, modern flavors to Midtown. It’s great for lunch crowds, workers on break, or anyone who loves unique slices.
Fan favorites:
-
Vodka slice
-
Pepperoni squares
-
Upside Down slice
It’s trendy, fast, and surprisingly high-quality, everything Midtown needs during the weekday rush.
5. Sofia Pizza Shoppe — Home of the Famous DoughDici Pie
Well-loved by locals, Sofia Pizza Shoppe has a loyal following thanks to their signature DoughDici pie—a thicker, artisanal square with a perfectly crisp edge.
Reasons to visit:
-
Excellent specialty pies
-
Well-balanced sauces
-
Hidden-gem energy
If you’re craving a unique spin on pizza, this is a must-try.
6. Patzeria Perfect Pizza — The No-Frills Spot with Big Flavor
Sometimes you want pizza that tastes like home—and Patzeria delivers exactly that. It’s one of the best quick-service spots in Midtown West, and the slices are consistently reliable.
Great for:
-
Pre-theater meals
-
Fast takeout
-
People craving a good classic slice without the hype
Its location near Broadway makes it a favorite among theatergoers.
7. 2 Bros Pizza — The Midtown Staple for Affordable Eats
For budget-friendly pizza that still hits the spot, 2 Bros is the go-to. No frills, no fuss—just solid slices at unbeatable prices.
Perfect for:
✔ Students
✔ Late-night bites
✔ Anyone who wants a classic slice without overspending
It’s pure, simple NYC comfort.
Popular Pizza Styles in Midtown Manhattan
Midtown’s pizza scene offers:
-
Classic New York slices
-
Sicilian and square pizza
-
Neapolitan pizza
-
Grab-and-go and sit-down pizza restaurants
Best Times to Grab Pizza in Midtown
-
Lunch breaks for office workers
-
Pre-Broadway show dinners
-
Late-night food near Times Square
Why Midtown Is a Pizza Lover’s Dream
Midtown isn’t just the center of business and tourism, it’s also quietly one of the best pizza neighborhoods in Manhattan. With a mix of iconic institutions, local favorites, and innovative newcomers, there's something for everyone.
If you’re exploring Manhattan or looking to build your own neighborhood food itinerary, these spots deserve a place on your list.
Final Thoughts: Midtown Is a Must-Visit for Pizza Lovers
Whether you’re hunting for the best pizza in Midtown Manhattan, NYC pizza near Times Square, or top pizza spots in Manhattan, Midtown delivers consistency, variety, and classic New York flavor.
With iconic slice shops, trusted institutions, and authentic Italian pizzerias, Midtown proves it deserves a spot on any NYC pizza guide.
